Craigslist.org single-handedly destroyed the giant newspaper classifieds

Mick Gregory

“You took over our advertising — now are you going to take over our news?” — a question from a San Francisco Chronicle journalist to Craig Newmark, founder and CEO of craigslist.org.

“We took a straw and drained your milkshake,” from “There Will Be Blood.”

Craigslist.org has dominated the classified advertising market with its free listings for everything from real estate — to jobs — to personals. Big city newspapers, like the SF Chronicle have been crippled by this new kid on the block.

How much traffic does craigslist get?
A: More than 10 billion page views per month

Q: How does that compare with other companies?
A: craigslist is #8 worldwide in terms of english-language page views

Q: How many people use craigslist?
A: More than 40 million each month, including more than 30 million in the US alone

Q: How many classified ads does craigslist receive?
A: craigslist users self-publish more than 30 million new classified ads each month

Q: How many job listings does craigslist receive?
A: More than 2 million new job listings each month

– The Q&A is from Craigslist.org

The average user/reader spends so much time on the site–about five days a month, 20 minutes per day–the site ranks a startling seventh in terms of monthly page views. This is 4 billion page views per month. A billion here, a billion there, now we are talking about real readership numbers.

So how exactly does Craigslist make money?

By charging $25 for job postings in six of its largest U.S. markets and $75 for job listings in San Francisco and by assessing a $10 fee for brokered apartment listings in New York City, according to their website.

Classified advertising was the real money-maker for newspapers. Want ads, are the little ads placed by individuals. They were not only the most profitable for newspapers on a word-for-word basis, they also generated great readership numbers, a fact that was lost on ALL of the newsrooms in America. The editor-centric news “executives” had not bothered to do any research on the readership of the ads that paid their salaries. They mocked MBAs, IT and celebrated BAs from America’s most liberal J-schools.

The arrogant editors who “manage” the entire newspaper enterprise, didn’t have a clue. They thought that they called the shots. People were paying 25  cents to read the ads just and a few pages of news and entertainment.

This just in from the Washington Post:

Let’s not bury the lead: This is a rough time for the newspaper business, a rough time for The Washington Post and a rough time for me.

No one need shed any tears for the people leaving this building. The more than 100 journalists who have just taken early-retirement packages are voluntarily accepting a generous offer as the company trims its payroll — a situation far better than at newspapers that have resorted to layoffs.

With advertising revenue sinking and classified competition from the likes of Craigslist, newspaper market values are taking a hit. Avista Capital Partners, which bought the Minneapolis Star Tribune 14 months ago, recently had to write down 75 percent of its investment. The purchase price had been $530 million; the previous owner, McClatchy Newspapers, paid $1.2 billion for the paper in 1998.

That’s just a few pieces to the puzzle of what went wrong. It’s not unlike the fall of family-owned business, where the next generation of trust-fund brats drain the profits and only find interest in the fun, ivory tower aspects of the business.

In these sob stories of more layoffs, there isn’t any mention of the marketing/advertising departments, because the editors have no interest in that aspect of the media.

If newspapers were run like real companies, there would have been “big picture” studies of trends and competition. How’s this for an idea, cut out five top level editors and buy 100 servers, two webmasters and one internet marketing guy.

What a concept.

About these ads

16 thoughts on “Craigslist.org single-handedly destroyed the giant newspaper classifieds

  1. Craigslist is awesome! It saves job seekers tons of money on stamps and sending in resumes. Amazing!

    Long Live Craigslist.

    If I wanted to look for Jobs in the NY Times Sunday Edition, I’d have to pay 4 dollars!

    Bow down to the Users, we’re running the show!!

    -Stal

  2. Chris Page, who covered local theater for the a suburban Arizona paper called the Tribune for the past five years was found dead Monday at his Mesa apartment. He was 29. He killed himself in grief because he was fired from the the money losing rag.

    Mesa police were called to the apartment by friends and former co-workers who hadn’t seen him since Wednesday. His body was inside, and he apparently committed suicide. According to police reports, Page apparently inhaled a fatal combination of potassium cyanide and muratic acid. That is a potent bomb.

    While at the Tribune, Page earned a fellowship to attend the NEA Arts Journalism Institute in Theater and Musical Theater at the USC Annenberg School for Communication. He won an Arizona Press Club award in 2005 for his coverage of Liza Minnelli’s performance at Mesa Arts Center, and shared another with co-workers in 2007 for a graphic that previewed the new Tempe Center for the Arts.

    Page also covered entertainment at the Bakersfield Californian from 2000 to 2003. In January, Page moved from covering theater for the Tribune to overseeing online features content. In early May, his position was included in a round of layoffs at the paper.

    I wonder if Joe Grimm read this. He’s the one at Poynteronline.org who soft sells newspaper careers.

  3. Pingback: unofficial craigslist blog » Time For Newspaper Industry To Re-Invent Itself

  4. Excellent points made by Mick. Spot on. Newspapers are dead in the water while Craigslist races past in a cigarette boat.

  5. Pingback: Free Job posting and classified adds on Craigslist.org « Topstockblog

  6. Pingback: Thanks for getting me there and back. « On The Edge of Sprawl

  7. I appreciate & use websites that actually INNOVATE vs. the newspapers who want to subject their viewers to constant NEGATIVE ‘NEWS’ & stories of crime/violence/etc. Craigslist is an online AD site, and I use it for that. Without all the garbage mixed in. Matter of fact, I would gladly PAY to use it. Newspaper websites? I’m more worried of how they spy on me, using their website. The newspapers are NOT to be trusted. Let them all burn in Hell!!

  8. Pingback: Moore's Law for Dummies | Tom Davidson

  9. Pingback: CharO unfairly slams Craigslist « Mark Turner dot Net

  10. I’m excited to uncover this site. I wanted to thank you for ones time for this fantastic read!! I definitely appreciated every bit of it and I have you book marked to look at new stuff on your website.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s